Where Are We Listening From?
A voice follows you through Linz. At first it is difficult to locate. It does not belong to a performer standing before an audience, nor does it arrive as a poem presented intact from beginning to end. It emerges from a loudspeaker somewhere along the Ars Electronica Festival Walk, enters the movement and noise of the city, and recedes again as you continue. Later it returns – or another fragment of it does. The voice speaks Ingeborg Bachmann’s Die gestundete Zeit, written more than seventy years before the festival. »There come harder days,« it warns, but the words do not stay in one place long enough to become a stable proclamation. They acquire distance and direction. Footsteps, conversations, traffic and architecture intervene. You do not possess the poem as a whole. You encounter it while moving.
This changes the poem, but it also changes the walk. A text that might otherwise appear to address us from the fixed space of the page becomes contingent upon where we happen to stand, which way we are moving and what else is sounding around us. The voice is not simply located in the city; it temporarily reorganises the city as a field of listening. A passage, a corner or a courtyard becomes perceptible as an acoustic situation.
At a festival concerned with Negotiating Humanity, this dispersed voice offers a useful place to begin. Much of the contemporary negotiation of the human occurs through images: facial recognition, synthetic pictures, avatars, robots and the visual evidence of artificial intelligence. Listening shifts the question. It asks not only what remains distinctively human, but where the human listener is situated in the first place. Across several works at Ars Electronica 2026, sound unsettles that position. A cathedral becomes an instrument. An organ pipe enters into negotiation with air, bodies and architectural resonance. Sunlight and moving tree shadows participate in a composition.
These works do not share a single aesthetic. They range from evala’s more-than-fifty-channel Holy Echo in the Mariendom, through Heike Kaltenbrunner’s intimate and unstable Noise of War, to the distributed electronic creatures of Matteo Holyoke Marangoni and Dieter Vandoren’s Komorebi.
What connects them is a spatial proposition: sound does not merely occur in space. It produces relations of distance, orientation, enclosure and proximity through which space becomes perceptible. To listen is always to listen from somewhere, but that »somewhere« is neither neutral nor fixed. It is composed through architecture, technology, environmental conditions and bodily movement.
The cathedral as an instrument
Entering Linz’s Mariendom after walking through the city produces an immediate change of scale. Outside, sound is dispersed across streets, crossings, conversations and moving bodies. Inside, the cathedral gathers it. Its height establishes a vertical axis; its long reverberation extends acoustic events beyond the moment of their production; its architecture makes distant sounds arrive as part of the volume immediately surrounding the listener. Even before evala’s Holy Echo begins, the building has organised the act of listening.
evala works with this condition rather than treating the cathedral as an impressive container for an otherwise autonomous composition. A spatial system of more than fifty loudspeaker channels activates different heights, distances and surfaces in the building. Sounds gather, move and dissolve into the Mariendom’s existing reverberation. At moments it becomes difficult to distinguish between a sound travelling through the technical system and the acoustic response of the architecture. One listens simultaneously to the composition and to the building being made audible by it.
This is consistent with evala’s long-running project See by Your Ears. The title can initially sound like a simple reversal of the familiar hierarchy between vision and hearing. But the proposition is more consequential. Hearing becomes a way of producing spatial knowledge. To »see« with the ears is to perceive relations – distance, movement, density, enclosure and scale – that reorganise how a place appears. Sound does not provide a substitute image of the cathedral. It discloses an architecture that cannot be separated from the duration and position of the listening body.
In our conversation after the performance, evala connected this to years of making field recordings in places where people experience some form of sacredness. His point was not that one particular acoustic property automatically makes a site sacred. Rather, sacred places often establish distinctive relations among sound, human presence and environment. In the European cathedral, architecture and organ traditionally gather dispersed listeners within a shared volume. The sound seems to descend, expand and surround. By contrast, evala associated sacred sites in Japan with a more open and horizontal acoustic orientation: environmental sounds arrive from multiple directions, without depending upon a monumental interior.
The distinction between Western verticality and Eastern horizontality should be treated cautiously. As a comprehensive cultural taxonomy, it risks becoming too schematic. Its importance here lies instead in the spatial imagination it opens. Listening has an orientation, and that orientation is culturally, architecturally and technologically produced. Vertical and horizontal do not simply identify the direction from which a sound arrives. They describe different possible relations between the listener and the surrounding world.
Holy Echo therefore negotiates humanity without representing a human figure. It changes the coordinates within which the human perceives itself. The listener is no longer positioned outside a technological object, observing what it does. One stands inside an acoustic field in which building, loudspeakers, reflections, software, recorded material and bodily position operate together.
The technical scale of the installation might suggest that this perceptual reorientation depends primarily upon technological sophistication. Yet evala repeatedly resisted that interpretation. He does not compose for a standard multichannel format that can subsequently be reproduced unchanged in different venues. The sound field is developed in relation to the particular acoustic environment. The Mariendom is not the site where a finished composition is installed; it participates in what the composition can become.
In the interview, evala described his relation to new technologies through the image of a child encountering an unfamiliar instrument. The child does not begin by attempting to operate it correctly or efficiently. The first response is to play, test and discover. As his interpreter formulated it, the important thing about using new technology is that it »makes the new perception.« Technology matters when it produces another possibility of sensing, not when it merely displays its own complexity.
This reverses a dominant arrangement in contemporary media. Screens, interfaces and headphones that increasingly generate a social listening deficit. Holy Echo places the culprit of such deficits inside the technical and architectural situation. There is no single exterior position from which listening can take place. The listener must move, attend and continually reorient.
Air, pipes and contingent rooms
A very different form of spatial negotiation appears in Heike Kaltenbrunner’s Noise of War, presented in the Church of the Sisters of St. Elizabeth. The work develops Kaltenbrunner’s proximity organ, an instrument in which organ pipes function as both sound generators and parts of a responsive technical system. Visitors do not encounter an organ operated from a distant keyboard. Their proximity affects the instrument, while airflow, pressure and the physical properties of the pipes shape what can emerge.
The title and material history of the work will become important later in this series. Zinc pipes carry histories of substitution, war and industrialised matter. But before the work becomes a question of memory, it is already a spatial event. An organ is never merely an object placed inside a room. Pipes, airflow, mechanical or electrical systems, architecture and the position of listeners operate together. The organ historically incorporates the building into its sounding body.
Kaltenbrunner both preserves and destabilises that relation. In the interview, she described how the pipes are tuned to fundamental tones, but sound under reduced and variable air pressure. A pipe tuned to E does not simply reproduce a stable E. Its fundamental may shift, while its overtones deviate by small intervals. At times only one overtone becomes prominent; at others several interact. The musical event occurs around the threshold between air, noise and tone rather than as the delivery of a predetermined pitch.
Watching visitors approach the work produces what might be called a theatre of listening without characters. Someone moves nearer to a pipe, but the effect is not necessarily exhausted at that moment. Air continues to build or dissipate. A tone can rise after the person who initiated a change has moved away. Another visitor may then encounter the acoustic residue of an interaction they did not witness. Cause, action and perception become spatially and temporally separated.
This complicates the familiar language of interactivity. The visitor does not press a button and receive an immediate, legible response. The instrument has inertia. Air must fill and leave the system. Pipes respond according to pressure, tuning and material conditions. The room extends the tones through reflection and reverberation. Listening becomes participation, but participation does not mean complete control.
Kaltenbrunner’s comments about presenting the instrument in different spaces make this especially clear. During the summer she had worked with it in the attic of a barn whose reverberation approached ten seconds. At Ars Electronica it occupied a peaceful church interior. A future presentation was planned for what she described as a white-cube situation – »acoustically totally different,« and, as our conversation added, contextually different too. For Kaltenbrunner, this variation is not simply an obstacle to be corrected. »It’s nice to explore different situations and see how it works,« she said.
The sentence is modest, but it names something central to the work. Noise of War does not possess one ideal spatial identity that every presentation must reproduce. Its identity includes the differences produced by each situation. A church lends the pipes associations with sacred music, collective listening and architectural transcendence. A barn offers another material and acoustic history. A white cube may isolate the object visually while reducing or transforming its reverberant life. The work travels, but it does not remain acoustically unchanged.
Kaltenbrunner had modified the instrument partly to make such travel possible. A wind machine replaced a heavier arrangement involving a bellows, reducing weight and noise; its protective enclosure could also serve as a transport box. Yet portability creates a productive contradiction. The apparatus becomes easier to move precisely so it can encounter spaces that alter it. Mobility does not free the work from site. It multiplies its situated forms.
Compared with Holy Echo, the scale and means are markedly different. evala uses an extensive spatial system to articulate the cathedral with considerable precision. Kaltenbrunner works with a compact instrument whose sounding remains vulnerable to slight changes in air pressure, visitor behaviour and room acoustics. In one case, spatial complexity is carefully constructed through many channels; in the other, it must continually be negotiated with unstable material conditions. Both works nevertheless refuse the idea that space is an empty volume awaiting sonic content. Space acts within the work.
An instrument played by the elements
From the church, the question of situated listening moves outdoors – or almost outdoors – to a quiet hospital garden in Linz. Here Matteo Holyoke Marangoni and Dieter Vandoren installed Komorebi, a distributed population of small electronic units that the artists call »creatures«. Some sit among the plants; others occupy trees. They produce tones, clicks and evolving phrases, but no fixed composition passes identically through them. Their behaviour responds to local conditions: sunlight, clouds, moving shadows, surrounding sounds and the activity of neighbouring creatures.
The title Komorebi names the Japanese phenomenon of sunlight filtering through leaves. The work does not illustrate this phenomenon by composing a stable musical representation of moving light. Instead, it constructs conditions through which variations in light can have sonic consequences. A sensor registers changes produced as wind moves a branch and shadows pass across a device. The electronic behaviour responds. Weather does not become a theme depicted by the work; it enters the work operationally.
Marangoni and Vandoren are wary of calling this a translation. Translation can imply that an input possesses a determinate meaning that is then rendered accurately in another medium. Their process is more like instrument building. »I like to talk about it as an instrument that is played by the elements,« Vandoren explained. The phrase preserves the artists’ compositional role while acknowledging that actual events depend upon forces they do not control.
This relation becomes audible in multiple ways. Changes in sunlight affect sustained behaviours, while microphones attend to acoustic events in the garden. The devices are especially responsive to the click-like sounds produced by other members of the group. Detected pitches and rhythms feed into phrase-generating processes; imperfect tracking and the simultaneous activity of many units allow patterns to change as they pass through the swarm. Each creature operates locally, yet the garden acquires a distributed and continuously developing sound field.
The site is therefore neither backdrop nor symbolic context. It supplies information to the system. The same garden at ten in the morning and four in the afternoon is not the same compositional situation. Overcast conditions produce subtler variations than intermittent sunlight. Wind reorganises the work by moving foliage. Human bodies may intervene by casting shadows or producing sound, but the installation does not wait exclusively for human action. Clouds move; plants alter the distribution of light; one artificial creature hears another. The composition continues even when no visitor stands at its centre.
This also complicates the hospital garden as a setting. Marangoni and Vandoren spoke about their wish to attune people to subtle environmental changes and about patients who spent long periods sitting among the works. But they resisted claiming a therapeutic function for art. Music can irritate one person and console another. The work may offer tranquillity, contemplation or a heightened connection to the surroundings, but it does not promise a cure. Its spatial politics are gentler and more open-ended: it makes a local environment available for another quality of attention.
The creatures’ apparent autonomy should not obscure the labour of composition. Their responses occur within behaviours, sensitivities and musical parameters developed over years. The artists described an ongoing struggle between allowing the swarm enough independence to surprise them and maintaining qualities they considered musically compelling. Site-specificity here does not mean surrendering authorship to nature. It means composing a field in which authorship cannot determine every event in advance.
Komorebi consequently extends the question raised by Holy Echo and Noise of War. In the cathedral, architecture becomes perceptible as an activated acoustic volume. In Kaltenbrunner’s installation, instrument and room negotiate through air, proximity and unstable overtones. In the hospital garden, environmental processes enter continuously into the work’s behaviour. These are not simply three different locations for sound art. They are three different ways in which location becomes active.
Listening without a centre
The familiar visual model of space assumes that a viewer can step back and survey a scene. Sound rarely permits such distance. It arrives from behind us and beyond the boundaries of vision. It passes through walls, reflects from surfaces and persists after its apparent source has stopped. We can close our eyes, but we cannot withdraw from an acoustic environment in the same way that we can look away from an image.
The works considered here intensify that condition. Holy Echo envelops the listener in an architecture made newly perceptible through technological composition. Noise of War produces delayed and unstable relations among bodies, air, pipes and room. Komorebi disperses composition through a field of local sensors and environmental changes. In each case, the listener loses the privilege of a single stable centre.
This is why evala’s distinction between vertical and horizontal listening remains useful once detached from a rigid geographical opposition. Horizontal listening can name a broader reorientation: the encounter with simultaneous relations that are not arranged solely around the human observer. In Komorebi, the most literal example, the human visitor is important but not sovereign. The creatures respond to the environment and to one another. In Noise of War, the visitor activates changes but cannot command precisely how air and overtone will develop. In Holy Echo, a listener’s position reveals only one perspective within a much larger spatial field.
Such reorientation does not remove the human from the work. It makes human perception situated. We listen with bodies that occupy particular locations, but also through architectures, technical systems and environmental conditions that precede our arrival. The question is not whether technology, buildings or weather listen as humans do. It is how their participation changes what human listening can become.
Somewhere along the Festival Walk, Bachmann’s voice emerges again. You approach it and the words become clearer; you continue walking and they begin to disappear. The poem has not moved, yet its acoustic relation to you changes with every step. The voice offers no overview of the city and no final position from which the festival can be understood. It does something more modest and more unsettling: it makes you aware that listening is always happening here, from this body, within these relations – and that »here« is already changing.
This is the first article in the series »Listening Otherwise: Three Reorientations at Ars Electronica«