Peer-reviewed audio paper

The Limitations of Sonic Offer

Vita Zelenska

11. december 2023

Fokus: WHAT SOUNDS DO

DOI https://doi.org/10.48233/06

Abstract

The sound of the slogans at the demonstrations touches the body, it is impossible to hide from. The vulnerability revealed through this touch creates immediate affective responses pointing at the limitations of sonic support and solidarization. Despite the trouble of misunderstanding that often comes with sonic action as these limitations become tangible, thinking through sonic clashes also opens possibilities for a better understanding of sonic action.

The audio paper includes recordings from the events in solidarity with migrants and refugees from 2020 to 2022 in Athens, along with the autoethnographic sonic material about a demonstration against the russian invasion into Ukraine. The autoethnographic audio message was not meant for public ear and documents the backstage of institutional knowledge production. This study emphasises the necessity of thinking about the limitations of sonic solidarity as a part of the political agency of sound. It theorises sonic conflict and misunderstanding, questioning solidarization through sound by paying attention to the discrepancies of language and affect.

Notes:

Quashie (2012, 72) has a valuable thought about quiet helping us “to understand the activism involved in being aware, in paying attention, in considering”. Quiet can serve to better our understanding of the affect of mourning that is not opposed to activism. They coexist in the second part of this paper.
Sedgwick (2007, 632) inspired the idea of ‘partial understanding’ in this paper through her discussion of “the middle ranges of agency – the notion that you can be relatively empowered or disempowered without annihilating someone else or being annihilated”.

Thank you Selbi Durdiyeva, Marina Karpova, and Julia Tulke for technical and editorial support.

My fieldwork was supported by the funding provided by the Leibniz ScienceCampus Regensburg “Europe and America in the Modern World”.

Bibliography

Nagar, R. (2014). Muddying the Waters: Coauthoring Feminisms across Scholarship and Activism. Urbana: University of Illinois Press.

Quashie, K. (2012). The Sovereignty of Quiet. Beyond Resistance in Black Culture. Rutgers University Press.

Sedgwick, E. K. (2007). Melanie Klein and the Difference Affect Makes. South Atlantic Quarterly, 106(3), pp. 626-642. Available at: doi:10.1215/00382876-2007-020

Further bibliography:

Hakli J., Kallio K.P. (2014). Subject, Action and Polis: Theorizing Political Agency. Progress in Human Geography, 38(2), pp. 181–200. Available at: doi:10.1177/0309132512473869 [Accessed 14 September 2023].

Kytö, M & Sirin, Ö.E. (2016). Sonic Resistance: Gezi Park Protests and the Political Soundscapes of Istanbul. in G Bottá (ed.), Unsichtbare Landschaften: Populäre Musik und Räumlichkeit – Invisible Landscapes: Popular Music and Spaciality. Populäre Kultur und Musik, no. 15, pp. 75-96.

Revill G. (2016). How is Space Made in Sound? Spatial Mediation, Critical Phenomenology and the Political Agency of Sound. Progress in Human Geography, 40(2), pp. 240–256. Available at: doi:10.1177/0309132515572271 [Accessed 14 September 2023].

Voegelin S. (2018). The Political Possibility of Sound: Fragments of Listening. New York: Bloomsbury Publishing.

Fokusartikler

Peer-reviewed audio paper

More Than Background

This audio paper explores the »acoustic territory« (Labelle, 2010) of Peckham Rye Lane through my sonic journey as a Peckham resident, practitioner, and researcher.

Francisco Mazza

11. december 2023

Peer-reviewed audio paper

Fear of Weakness

In the audio-paper »Fear of Weakness: Songs to Agitate the Man«, artist Morten Poulsen builds on his project »Boys Will Be…« (2022), in which he met with young cis-men to have conversations about vulnerability, intimacy and masculine norms

Morten Poulsen

11. december 2023

Anna Kûitse Thastum and her grandddaughter playing the Inuit frame drum qilaat. Photographer unknow

Peer-reviewed audio paper

The Heartbeat of the Drum

For over 4000 years, the Inuit in Kalaallit Nunaat, as Greenland is called in Greenlandic, have been living in an intimate relationship with nature in the Arctic. Their knowledge of how to survive under such harsh conditions has been preserved and passed on via sound through the millennia.

Ania Mauruschat

11. december 2023

Peer-reviewed audio paper

The Limitations of Sonic Offer

Vita Zelenska

11. december 2023

Peer-reviewed article

The human body as a space defining element of sound art

This article researches the role of the Human body in the production of sound art in the exhibition space. It focuses on the spatial path between body and sound in the exhibition space of sound art.

Andromachi Vrakatseli

11. december 2023

Peer-reviewed article

Sound as Shield

The essay probes poetics and the politics of a life-affirming operation in which Ukrainians have been self-engaged to resist subjugation and assimilation under Russian colonialism.

Olya Zikrata

6. Januar 2024

Peer-reviewed audio paper

TO WHOM IT MAY SPEAK

This audio paper narrates through the experiences and ambiences of Russian aggression to which Ukrainians relate a long history of Russia’s imperial statehood.

Olya Zikrata

11. december 2023

Peer-reviewed audio paper

The Second Sound of Integrity

Following Ruiz and Vourloumis, this audio paper performance sounds a formless formation, exploring integrity and wholeness among Black and Indigenous collectives that organize via radical forms of togetherness outside state-sponsored institution

Emery Petchauer ,
Ruth Nicole Brown

11. december 2023

Peer-reviewed article

The Lyric Ear

The article analyses the genre of listening scores – texts written in a natural language that provide the readers with instructions to listen in a certain way or to a certain kind of sounds.

Vadim Keylin

11. december 2023

Peer-reviewed article

Democratic Noise

Democratic conversation and collectively improvised music have such pronounced similarities that improvisations can be discussed in terms of their democratic potentiality.

Noa Grønhøj,
Jakob Kjær Bødker

11. december 2023

Peer-reviewed audio paper

Karaoke Collage

I went on an artist residency in Tokyo in 2018/19 for three months and ended up spending most of my time in karaoke boxes. I don’t remember what my actual project was but in the birthplace of karaoke, amateur singing of pop songs was all I could think of.

Ragnhild May,
Kristoffer Raasted

11. december 2023

Voice as Infrastructure

This audio paper explores the phenomenon of voice-based technology in the smart-home. Through ethnographic interviews we study how older people use voice-based technologies and with what effects for their experiences of the affective environment in their homes.

Marie Ertner,
Stina Hasse Jørgensen,
Signe L. Yndigegn

11. december 2023

Peer-reviewed audio paper

Cochlear implantation surgery

Operating rooms are typically noise filled environments, where polyrhythms and polyphonics of human and non-human sounds collide. In this paper the operating room soundscape is used for relational ethnographic exploration, framed in critical affect theory, and brings together insights from medical sociology and sound studies.

Andile Lindokuhle Sibiya,
Kevin Gordon,
Matthias Kispert

11. december 2023

Peer-reviewed audio paper

Dynamics of Power Dynamics

It is through knowledge of the art-form and skilful weaving of networks of symbols, that creatives can dictate the terms of storytelling and thus exert their power over the audience.

Carlos Manrique Clavijo

31. Januar 2024